How Google and Amazon hire – and what a smaller company can borrow

The Rule of Four and an independent assessor in every hiring process. What big tech’s experience can offer a smaller business.
A team discussing candidates together at a laptop

Hiring at big tech companies can look out of reach for a smaller business: multi-stage interviews, specially trained assessors, teams of analysts. Yet the ideas behind Google’s and Amazon’s approach are fairly simple. They can be applied even if you hire only a handful of people a year.

Google: the Rule of Four

Google’s former head of people, Laszlo Bock, has described how hiring at the company used to take six to nine months, with candidates going through a long string of interviews. Analyst Todd Carlisle checked how many interviews were actually needed. He found that four interviews were enough to predict with 86% confidence whether a candidate should be hired.

After the so-called Rule of Four was introduced, time to hire fell from about six months to 45 days. Another Google finding concerns grades: according to Bock, they are slightly predictive of performance for the first couple of years after university, and barely matter after that. What counts far more is what a person has learned and how quickly they learn.

Amazon: an independent assessor

Since 1999, Amazon has run its “Bar Raiser” programme. An experienced, extensively trained assessor takes part in the selection process and usually works in a different team from the one hiring. They are under no pressure to fill the role quickly, so they can assess more objectively whether the candidate meets the company’s leadership principles. They also help the hiring manager prepare for interviews and draw up questions.

The programme’s goal is stated simply: every person hired should be better than half of those currently in similar roles. In other words, every hiring decision should raise the current standard, not just maintain it.

What a smaller company can borrow

  • Limit the number of interviews. Choose the number of interviews based on what needs to be tested for the specific role. Agree in advance what you want to find out in each interview.
  • Bring in someone from outside the team. When you need someone urgently, it can be harder to calmly weigh up all of a candidate’s strengths and doubts. A colleague from another department or an external consultant can help spot what has been left undiscussed.
  • Agree on assessment criteria before the interviews. Write down what results and abilities you expect. Also discuss how the new employee should work with the team.
  • Assess the experience and abilities that matter for the role. For an experienced candidate, what they have achieved in recent years matters more than where and how they graduated.
  • Track the outcomes. Even a simple table – who was hired and how they are doing a year later – will show over time which hiring decisions hold up.

Clear criteria applied consistently help organise recruitment even in a small company. A smaller company can make decisions faster, but every mistake costs it relatively more. We wrote more about the cost of recruitment and of replacing an employee in our article on recruitment costs.

Sources: Knowledge at Wharton, “Open Sourcing Google’s HR Secrets” (2016); Bock, L. (2015). Work Rules!; Amazon, “What is a Bar Raiser at Amazon?”.