A recruitment agency can save a lot of time and reduce the risk of a wrong hire when you choose a partner who understands your needs. Below are the questions worth asking before signing a contract, and what to look out for in the answers.
1. How do you find candidates?
Ask whether the agency relies only on job ads and its own candidate database, or also does direct search. Finding managers and rare specialists usually means approaching people who aren’t looking for a job. If the answer stops at “we have a large database”, ask how they will reach the people who aren’t in it. We cover the differences in more detail in the article Headhunting or standard recruitment.
2. Do you have experience in our field?
An agency that knows your field understands the role faster, knows where to look for candidates and can judge their salary expectations realistically. Ask them to tell you about similar roles they have filled recently. They don’t need to reveal names or companies, but the answer should be specific.
3. How do you assess candidates?
The experience listed in a CV needs to be discussed in more depth and assessed for its relevance to the specific role. Ask how the agency checks competencies, motivation and team fit: whether it uses structured interviews, practical tasks or personality assessment tools, and whether it collects references. It is also worth discussing how you will assess candidates yourself and how both sides’ assessments will be combined.
4. What do we get besides a list of candidates?
It is valuable to get a short market assessment before the search – how many suitable people there are and what salaries they expect – and later candidate profiles with an assessment and recommendation. If the agency simply forwards CVs without comment, much of the assessment work is left to you.
5. How long does the search take?
Ask for a realistic timeline and an explanation of what it depends on. A search for a scarce specialist or a manager rarely ends within a couple of weeks. If a shorter timeline is offered, it is worth discussing how the search and candidate assessment will be carried out within it.
6. What guarantee do you provide?
Find out what happens if the person you hire leaves in the first months: is the search repeated free of charge, how many times, within what period, and does the guarantee apply if you are the one who lets the employee go? These terms should be in the contract, not just mentioned in a meeting.
7. How is the fee calculated?
It is important to understand the model – success fee, fixed fee or retainer – and exactly what the price includes: market analysis, assessment tools, advertising costs. Also ask what happens if you pause the search or the role changes. We cover pricing models in more detail in the article on the cost of recruitment.
8. Who exactly will run our search?
It is worth meeting the person who will run your search in advance. Discuss how many projects they are working on at the same time and how often you will receive updates on the search.
What to discuss before you start working together
Choose a partner who clearly explains the process, the fee and the guarantee, knows your field and takes the time to understand your team. TrustHire works on a limited number of searches, aims to complete a search within 6 weeks and provides a 3-month guarantee. You will find answers to other questions in our FAQ, and you can discuss your position by contacting us.
