When your best employee brings you another employer’s offer

How to discuss another employer’s offer, find out what the employee expects and assess whether higher pay would solve the problems they have raised.
A manager and an employee discussing an offer from another employer

One of a manager’s harder conversations starts something like this: “I have received an offer from another company.” The first reaction is often to offer more. Higher pay can help reach an agreement, but first it is important to understand why the person is considering leaving.

First, find out why they were looking

An employee who brings you an offer has usually already been through several interviews with the other employer. That means the decision to look around was made weeks or months ago. So don’t ask “How much did they offer you?” – ask “What made you start talking to them?”.

The answers usually fall into a few groups:

  • pay is behind the market, and the employee has found out;
  • there is no clear path forward – they cannot see their next step in the company;
  • the relationship with their manager or team;
  • the work itself: too little challenge, too much routine, or the reverse;
  • personal circumstances: commute, flexibility, workload.

We wrote in more detail about why employees leave, and where pay sits among the reasons, in a separate article.

When it is worth making a counteroffer

If the employee is considering leaving only because of pay, it is worth considering raising it to market level. At the same time, it is worth reviewing how and when the company checks whether salaries match the market. If one person’s salary is lagging behind, others in the same group may be lagging too.

If the reason is prospects, relationships or the content of the work, higher pay does not solve the problem. If the underlying reason is not addressed, the wish to change jobs may come back.

Consequences worth thinking about

  • The signal to the team. If others learn that bringing in an outside offer is the way to get a raise, it becomes an unwritten rule.
  • A changed relationship. It is important to discuss openly how you will work going forward and what changes both sides expect.
  • Consistency of your pay system. From 2027, employees will be able to request information on the average pay, broken down by gender, of employees doing the same work or work of equal value, so exceptions will be harder to justify. More on this in our article on the Pay Transparency Directive.

How to handle the conversation

  1. Thank the employee for being open with you rather than simply handing in their resignation.
  2. Do not rush to promise changes before assessing them. Ask for a day or two and say clearly when you will respond.
  3. Find out the reasons and ask directly: “If the pay were the same, would you still be thinking of leaving?”
  4. Offer only what you can deliver. A promise of promotion “next year” without a concrete plan usually just delays the departure.
  5. If the employee decides to leave, agree on an orderly handover and keep the relationship respectful. References and the option of returning in the future can matter to both sides.

Regular conversations about pay, professional growth and the content of the work help you understand an employee’s expectations before they receive another offer. We wrote about what your best employees think when a headhunter calls in this article.